tony-and-liliana-delvecchio.com

“As soon as Winston had dealt with each of the messages, he clipped his speakwritten corrections to the appropriate copy of The Times and pushed them into the pneumatic tube. Then, with a movement which was as nearly as possible unconscious, he crumpled up the original message and any notes that he himself had made, and dropped them into the memory hole to be devoured by the flames.”

– 1984, George Orwell

            Tommy combed the internet regularly, looking for any sign of his daughter. There were a few snippets here and there, old stuff mostly about Livy’s ballet class but little else. She had disappeared from his life by and large, and even if he thought about trying to find her, he didn’t know where to look. Tommy assumed she was living with her grandparents and her mother up in Chiba, but that was just speculation on his part. He really had no idea where to actually look for her. Strangely, that all changed when a random student of his at one of his gigs — a continuing education class — approached him after class and told him he had some information about his daughter.

            Tommy was shocked at this odd incident. The student told him that he was a father too and that he felt sorry about what had happened to him, offering to help him learn about what had become of his daughter. Turns out this guy had, in fact, a great deal of information about which Tommy was previously unaware, including where his daughter’s mother worked and what university Livy was attending. How he had come about this information, Tommy didn’t know, but there it was. Tommy felt more than a little bit uncomfortable about this bizarre intrusion into his personal life by a man he had only recently met in his after-hours English course, yet he could not help but want to know more. The extent of the details this person brought before him was truly overwhelming.

            One of the things he came to find out was that Livy was no longer using her mother’s last name, but in fact was using the last name of the man Tommy knew his ex-wife had been having an affair with while they were married. This was a new revelation as the information he had about her last name was by way of a “nastygram” from a lawyer working on behalf of Livy’s mother and Livy herself threatening him with a lawsuit unless he scrubbed the internet of all mention of Livy on left-behind parent sites and the like. This had all come about after Tommy had published an article in a local magazine detailing his experiences as a left-behind father and which mentioned his ex by name.
Armed with this new knowledge — Livy’s new last name and the university she was attending — Tommy was able to find mentions of her in school publications. Not only that, but now that he knew her new last name, Tommy was able to see pictures of Livy on her Facebook account. It just had never occurred to him to search under his ex-wife’s lover’s last name. But there she was, emerging from the void after years of absence.

            What he found, though, distressed him. Not only did she bear the name of the adulterer who played a big part in the dissolution of his marriage to his faithless wife, but in short bios he read from her she is now telling the world that she was not half-American, half-Japanese, but instead, half-New Zealand, half-Japanese. He also learned from her mother’s social media account that his ex-wife set her marriage date as occurring a full six months before the date that he had married her. And oddly, exactly one year before Livy’s birth.

Livy’s entire life now, he thus learned, was predicated on a massive lie. Tommy had been utterly erased from his daughter’s life by way of the artifice of a faithless wife and the man she slept with throughout her marriage to him. Tommy finally understood why Livy had never reached out to him over the past twenty years, fearful of the world learning the truth of where she really came from. Tommy figured this lie appeared on all of her bios, resumes, and social media accounts, and understood the danger that she faced had the world learned the reality of her existence. It was not enough to remove Livy from her life, Tommy’s very existence needed to be obliterated. And so, while the Japanese legal system rendered him an un-parent by law, Livy’s mother and her paramour felt it necessary to erase him entirely from the picture as if he had never existed.

            Such was the reality he now lived in. As far as Japan was concerned, there was no Tommy DeVito. He had become a phantom, a figment of somebody’s imagination, a non-person as far as his daughter was concerned. This was, indeed, the unkindest cut of all. The futility of a once hoped for reunion now became apparent to him. He had truly lost her to this cruel fiction.

“If a man dwells on the past, then he robs the present. But if a man ignores the past, he may rob the future. The seeds of our destiny are nurtured by the roots of our past.”

– Master Po, “The Tide”, Kung Fu television series

            Tommy remembers reading somewhere some advice a Buddhist monk had given about how to avoid slipping into depression. The monk said that if you are already troubled, it’s not a good idea to sit alone in a room listening to sad music. Sounded very sensible, he thought, and yet that is what he found himself doing increasingly often these days. Tommy knew it wasn’t a good idea, but he did it anyway. Because, he thought, that’s all he had left of her, and nobody was going to take that away from him.

           Tommy called this The Well of Sadness, a place to which you go even though you know you should not. He was seemingly driven by an unquenchable thirst to feel, to somehow connect with that which once was, but is no more. Across a seemingly limitless desert he would trek, feeling the searing heat of the unadulterated sun upon his back, while he tried in the bright light of day to make sense of the loss and alienation that had become his life.

           The vast expanse of endless sand – this emptiness – served to place some distance between himself and that which he knew would cause him pain. The desert has no memory, and so he could become lost in a wilderness of his own making, where the bad things could not harm him. The starkness allowed no place for the monsters to hide.

            Inevitably, though, he would thirst and he knew he must drink. The memories are the only thing, he believed, capable of hydrating his withered soul, and restoring this shell of a father, this man both with child yet without child, this once upon a father, this curious artifact of a family living alone in his now empty home. Left behind.

            Thus, he would make his way to the Well. There the water was cool and refreshing. It let him experience ever so briefly the happiness that he felt as a parent in days gone by, in that place that was displaced from him in time. It reminded him that it was real, that even though he wandered through the desert now as one cast aside, it had really happened, that once he was Daddy to a little girl. Yet the water in the Well, he knew, was unsafe to drink. Memories that bring most parents delight inevitably cause intense pain, and he would always find himself doubled over, cursing the ladle that brought the water to his lips. And though he knew that he must stop, the Well called unto him, and invited him to drink. “More. More.” And he could not resist.

            The house in which he now dwelt had become a museum, dedicated to the memory of his only child. Here were the dusty toys he had bought for her on those many birthdays and Christmases. There were the books they once read together, now left unread, their pages yellowing with age as they sat forgotten upon the shelf. There were the pictures on the wall that evoked memories of amusement parks they had been to and of family gatherings with grandparents, uncles and aunts, and cousins who once played and laughed and ate together.

            He had thought about moving – getting out of this place that held so many bittersweet memories of the kid. Being here was most often painful for him now, and yet he never could bring himself to leave. Here is where she took her first baby bath, walked her first steps, and spoke her first words. The park up the street is where he pushed her on the swing, where they dug in the sand pit together, and where they lit sparklers in the summertime. These are the streets where first he carried her, then pushed her in the stroller, and later held her hand as they walked together. No, as much as it pained him to stay, he knew he couldn’t leave this place behind, leave whatever was left of her behind. The memories this place evoked was all he had left of her now, and so he resigned himself to being this ghost of a father who haunted the past of the love he and the kid had once shared together. Here is where he would remain, despite the contradictory desire in his soul to flee the torment that besieged this now daughterless father, this aging receptacle of what he used to be which existed now only in his mind.

            Tommy knew what only the left-behind parent knew – that the heart doesn’t break just once, but over and over again, every day of your life. There is no such thing as “closure” when you lose a child. While it may be true that the frequency of the painful episodes may decrease somewhat with time, it always lurks just beneath the surface and threatens to attack without notice at the slightest trigger – the sound of a little girl giggling somewhere outside, an advertisement for the Cartoon Network on TV, a hair clip found between the folds of the sofa, or the sight of the baby’s drinking cup in the kitchen cabinet that has been seen a hundred times before, but for some reason causes an unexpected trip “down memory lane” this time. The sadness, he knew, came unexpectedly, like a rogue wave on an otherwise relatively peaceful sea which threatens to capsize and drown you in the immensity of your grief.

            Parental alienation was not something that you “get over” or recover from but is rather akin to learning to live with a disability and make adjustments to so that you can somehow function as a “normal person” in the outside world. While at first the pain is on full display for friends and family to see, at some point you try to keep it to yourself as much as possible out of a sense of shame and the belief that you have to “man up” and “get on with your life.” Tommy’s father once told him in reference to his ex that he “shouldn’t let her ruin your life,” and yet the damage has already been done — the ruination was an unalterable fact. This is not to say that you curl up in a fetal position in the corner and stop living your life, but instead it is simply an acknowledgement that in many ways you know you will never truly be the same as you were before – that something has been irretrievably lost. And so you learn to wait until the darkness of night descends in your house and cry alone when no one else is around to hear it.

“Sleeplessness comes when my thoughts outweigh the night.”
― Terri Guillemets

                  Tommy stared off once again into the darkness, the silence of the night defeaning in its intensity. And he knew that once again the fight to attain sleep, to gratefully fall into the arms of Morpheus, had begun anew.

                  It was at these times that he knew there was no respite from the insistence of memory, that the clarion call for reflection was relentless, and that he was defesneless against its demands. The line that seemingly separated the then from the now was illusory at these times, and that despite his efforts to the contrary, he would be once again be transported to that place of long ago, as fresh in its palpability as if those decades past had occurred only yesterday.

                  And he knew that it was only a matter of time before the tears were to fall anew.

                  During the day, his life was full of the distractions necessary to overcome the sadness that dwelt in his heart, waiting like a thief in the ngiht to ambush him from the carefully sequestered recesses of his mind. In the day, there was work, there were friends to banter with, there were bills to pay and plans for the future to be made. But lying in bed at night, there was nothing to stop him from the haunting reminiscence of those days gone by.

                 Sometimes he was able to put up a valiant fight against the onslaught of the bittersweet memories of the fatherhood that was denied him by practicing a sort of Zen absence of mind. But more often than not, “thinking about nothing” would lose out to the inevitable exhortations of his own mind to replay again and again the times when he was not the shadow of a father that he had now become. In this relentless pursuit of peace, he knew that he was going to try yet again to figure out what went wrong and what he could possibly have done to prevent it, despite the fact that ultimately there would be no answers to the questions that plagued him in the quiet and lonely hours of the night.

                In these moments, he knew that he was ultimately powerless against the tide of remembrances that would sweep him out into that sea of despair that he sought to avoid. In the light of day, he could pretend that he had long since built up an immunity to the pain of the loss that he had experienced when Livy’s mother took him out of her life. At these times, he sometimes wished he could erase all traces of the kid that had once been the entirety of his life. At these times, he wished he could “wipe the slate claen” and live a life unencumbered by the multitude of still frames of he and his daughter together that flashed before his mind.

               Nevertheless, he knew also that these memories, however sad and injurious they had become to him now, were all that he had left of her. And so he clung to them even as they tore at his soul, hoping that somehow he would be able to smile at the thoughts of the happy times he shared with Livy. He hoped that somehow he could find a path that led him not to the torment of that loss, but instead to a reconcilation that would allow him to accept the unacceptable, to what the Emperor Hirohito described as “enduring the unendurable.”

             And so he waited in the silence for the exhaustion of the effort to make sense of the past would eventually overwhlem him, until the tears dried up and he would at last drift off into a state of blissful unconsciousness, ever mindful that even then the dreams might come to rouse him from the tranquility of his slumber. And that with the rising sun, he could somehow, some way, construct anew a fortress against the pain of the night that would visit him. And as the morning light hit his eyes, he held out hope that he could shield himself against the onslaught of memories that should comfort him, but which instead sought to diminish him.

“We have consulted our wishes rather than our reason

in the indulgence of an idea of accommodation.”

General Nathanael Greene, Revolutionary War Hero

commenting on the futility of appeasement with

King George III of England during the American Revolution

              After he and his wife separated, Tommy wondered just how he was going to extricate himself from their loveless marriage. Initial attempts to “come to some sort of agreement” looked increasingly futile. Prior to breaking up, they had planned to stay together until Livy graduated from kindergarten, and then set up separate residences nearby one another so that they could share in Livy’s upbringing. It was to be a more or less “amicable” divorce at first. However, when certain “revelations” came to light as what was really going on when his wife was supposedly “visiting friends,” Tommy lost it and kicked her out of the house. “Get the fuck out of my house!” were, in fact, the actual words he used to end their cohabitation a year ahead of schedule.

                After the separation, there began a brief period of limbo in which an uncertain future lay ahead. That period ended a few months later upon receipt of the suit for divorce, followed by a mandatory period of “mediation” by the family court. The divorce still could have been worked out more or less amicably, despite the bitterness and resentment the two felt. In Japan, a divorce can be attained simply by going to the local ward office and filing a form. But this was not going to happen, and a long and costly road was to stretch out ahead lasting almost three years.

               After hiring an attorney, the first step in the arcane Japanese divorce process was mediation. Tommy fully expected that the two parties would sit at a table accompanied by their lawyers to try to arrive at a mutually acceptable way out of the marriage. His first surprise was to learn that he and his soon-to-be ex were not to face each other this way, but instead would meet with the two mediators individually, each in turn. The results of any conversations or demands by each party would then be laboriously relayed to the other through these third party intermediaries – in other words, “the Japanese way”. Nevertheless, Tommy thought that eventually the details could somehow be hammered out in this ludicrous fashion. What alternative was there really than to play the game through this irrational process. It wasn’t until one of the mediators actually told him straight to his face that he could never expect to receive legal custody of his daughter because he “wasn’t Japanese and didn’t have a kosseki (family registry)” that Tommy realized he was well and truly fucked. He was playing this card game against a marked deck, and at this moment he knew that he was never going to win. The best he could hope for was to wear out his adversary and hope to extract whatever meaningful concessions he could manage. That is, if the process didn’t ruin him first.

                  The next surprise in store for Tommy was learning that in Japan, unlike in the other G-7 countries, kyoudou shinken (joint custody) did not exist. Children born of a marriage are treated as chattel, to be awarded completely to one party or the other. The victorious parent in the divorce proceedings receives exclusive parental rights while the loser is stripped entirely of those rights and becomes, in essence, a non-parent, with no more parental rights than a perfect stranger. The parent who wins in a divorce dispute, then, retains all legal rights with respect to any and all decisions regarding the child’s life. In truth, parental rights in Japan can be divided into shinken (legal custody) and kango ken(physical custody). Realizing he would surely lose legal custody, Tommy during the mediation suggested bifurcating the matter, giving his wife physical custody while he retained legal custody so that he could maintain contact with Livy. The mediators quickly shot that idea down – dishonestly told him it was impossible —  and Tommy was left with only one option for staying in his daughter’s life – an enforceable visitation arrangement.

                That was his next surprise. While the non-custodial parent can be made to pay child support by law, no provisions for enforceable visitation existed in Japanese statutes. After the farcical mediation phase had broken down, Tommy was told during regular court proceedings that the two issues – child support and visitation – were “separate matters,” and while the court could enforce child support, it could not do anything to compel regular visitation if the prevailing party – the parental rights holder –  did not allow it. The only hope he had now was to refuse to permit to the divorce and hope that his ex would eventually, voluntarily provide a legally binding contract with regard to visitation that could actually be enforced in the courts.

                Frustrated that Tommy continued to insist on regular, enforceable visitation, however, his mother’s daughter – the term he now used to refer to his soon-to-be ex-wife – got her back up and would only grant visitation “as long as the child did not object.” After nearly three years in the divorce process, it got to the point where the judge was about to render a decision, and Tommy was advised in no uncertain terms that that decision would not – could not legally – provide any enforceable mechanism to ensure that Tommy could maintain contact with his kid. In other words, he was faced with accepting a flawed “agreement” with a loophole so large that a shinkansen could drive through or get no agreement at all.

               Nothing Tommy could have done throughout the whole circus, he eventually came to accept, would have changed the outcome. His loss was preordained from the start, and the war of attrition he hoped would somehow compel a sensible parental rights agreement was ultimately a failed and vainglorious attempt, although he had no other course but to pursue it. And so, after three years of exhausting and in the end fruitless “negotiations” with an intractable adversary, Tommy ultimately signed an agreement that was no more substantial than the gossamer of his middle-aged dreams. Tommy signed the sham of an agreement and never saw his daughter again.